Choosing the Right Magnet for Your Electric Motor: A Technical Guide
Selecting the optimal magnet for electric motors directly impacts efficiency (up to 98% in premium designs), manufacturing costs (magnets account for 25-50% of motor material costs), and operational lifespan. With industries like EVs and industrial automation demanding higher power density, understanding these four magnetic properties is essential for engineers and designers.
1. Remanence (Br): The Power Driver
Remanence (Br) measures residual magnetic flux density after magnetization, expressed in Tesla (T). Higher Br values enable:
-
Compact designs: A 1.4T NdFeB magnet produces 40% more flux than a 0.4T ferrite magnet, reducing motor size.
-
Higher torque: EV motors using N52-grade NdFeB (Br=1.48T) achieve 15% faster acceleration vs. ferrite alternatives.
Trade-off: High-Br materials like neodymium are sensitive to demagnetization at >150°C.
2. Energy Product (BHmax): Efficiency Multiplier
The energy product (kJ/m³ or MGOe) defines stored magnetic energy. Compare common materials:
-
Ferrite (3–5 MGOe): Low-cost but requires 5x more volume than NdFeB.
-
NdFeB (35–52 MGOe): Enables 90% weight reduction in drone motors.
-
Samarium Cobalt (25–32 MGOe): Ideal for aerospace (stable at 300°C).
Case Study: A 10kW industrial pump motor switched from ferrite to NdFeB, cutting magnet weight from 4.2kg to 0.8kg while maintaining output.
3. Intrinsic Coercivity (Hcj): Demagnetization Defense
Coercivity (kA/m) indicates resistance to external fields. Critical in applications like:
-
EV inverters: High-frequency PWM signals create reverse fields up to 300kA/m.
-
Wind turbines: Lightning strikes generate destructive magnetic pulses.
Rule: Select Hcj values 20–30% above the system’s maximum reverse field. For example, NdFeB grades like 48H (Hcj=1,120kA/m) outperform standard N42 (Hcj=955kA/m) in harsh conditions.
4. Curie Temperature (Tc): Thermal Limits
The Curie point determines irreversible magnetic loss. Key thresholds:
Material | Tc (°C) | Safe Operating Temp (°C) |
---|---|---|
Ferrite | 450 | ≤180 |
NdFeB | 310 | ≤150 |
SmCo | 800 | ≤300 |
Failure Example: A CNC machine motor using NdFeB reached 170°C due to poor cooling, causing 12% flux loss and $8,200/year in downtime.
Material Selection Guide
Parameter | Ferrite | NdFeB | SmCo |
---|---|---|---|
Cost ($/kg) | 3–5 | 50–100 | 120–200 |
Corrosion Resistance | High | Low* | High |
Temp Stability | Good | Poor | Best |
*NdFeB requires nickel/ epoxy coating. |
Application-Based Recommendations:
-
Budget Motors: Ferrite + increased stator slots.
-
High-Speed Motors: SmCo for <0.1% flux loss at 250°C.
-
Consumer Electronics: Coated NdFeB for miniaturization.
Avoid These 3 Common Mistakes
-
Ignoring Dynamic Demagnetization: Test magnets under load (not just static Br).
-
Overlooking Machining Costs: Sintered NdFeB adds $20–50/kg for precision shaping.
-
Miscalculating Air Gaps: A 0.5mm error reduces flux by 9–15%.
Ignoring Dynamic Demagnetization: Test magnets under load (not just static Br).
Overlooking Machining Costs: Sintered NdFeB adds $20–50/kg for precision shaping.
Miscalculating Air Gaps: A 0.5mm error reduces flux by 9–15%.
Need Custom Solutions?
Contact TECOMAG’s engineering team for:
✅ Free material analysis
✅ Demagnetization curve modeling
✅ ISO-certified prototyping
sales01@tecomag.net | info@tecomag.net